Don Boudreaux on Public Choice in Politics

Don Boudreaux of George Mason University talks with EconTalk host Russ Roberts about public choice: the application of economics to the political process. Boudreaux argues that political competition is a blunt instrument that works less effectively than economic competition. One reason for this bluntness is the voting process itself--where intensity does not matter, only whether a voter prefers one candidate to the other. A second reason is that political outcomes tend to be one-size-fits-all, which often leads to dissatisfaction. Boudreaux defends the morality of not voting, while Roberts, who does vote from time to time, concedes that one's vote is almost always irrelevant in determining the outcome.

Play

Time: 1:09:26

How do I listen to a podcast?

Download

Size: 31.8 MB

Right-click or Option-click, and select "Save Link/Target As MP3.

Readings and Links related to this podcast

Podcast Readings HIDE READINGS

About this week's guest: Don Boudreaux's Home page Cafe Hayek. Don Boudreaux's blog (with Russ Roberts) About ideas and people mentioned in this podcast: Books: Collected Works of James M. Buchanan, 9 vols. available on Econlib.In print, 20 vols. available individually or as a set from Liberty Fund, Inc. Articles: "Public Choice," by William Shughart II. Concise Encyclopedia of Economics. "Rent Seeking," by David R. Henderson. Concise Encyclopedia of Economics. David Hume. Biography. Concise Encyclopedia of Economics. Friedrich A. Hayek. Biography. Concise Encyclopedia of Economics. James Buchanan. Biography. Concise Encyclopedia of Economics. Kenneth Arrow. Biography. Concise Encyclopedia of Economics. Web Pages: Southeast Texas Nursery Growers' Association. (Could find no website yet for the Southwest Texas association.) Podcasts and Blogs: Garett Jones on Macro and Twitter. EconTalk podcast. Boettke on Elinor Ostrom, Vincent Ostrom, and the Bloomington School. Shame and other cultural deterrents of undesirable behavior. EconTalk podcast. Caplan on the Myth of the Rational Voter. EconTalk podcast. Giving Away Money: An Economist's Guide to Political Life. EconTalk podcast. Previous episodes featuring Don Boudreaux. EconTalk podcasts.

Politicians solve exactly whose problems?

Thomas Sowell is one of my favourite authors. He summarises it neatly here when he discusses how politicians motivations are not always (ever?) aligned with the citizens... (complete article is here).

No one will really understand politics until they understand that politicians are not trying to solve our problems. They are trying to solve their own problems-- of which getting elected and re-elected are number one and number two. Whatever is number three is far behind.

Many of the things the government does that may seem stupid are not stupid at all, from the standpoint of the elected officials or bureaucrats who do these things.

The current economic downturn that has cost millions of people their jobs began with successive administrations of both parties pushing banks and other lenders to make mortgage loans to people whose incomes, credit history and inability or unwillingness to make a substantial down payment on a house made them bad risks.

Was that stupid? Not at all. The money that was being put at risk was not the politicians' money, and in most cases was not even the government's money. Moreover, the jobs that are being lost by the millions are not the politicians' jobs-- and jobs in the government's bureaucracies are increasing.......